.razor files don't use C# formatting settings

[vsfeedback]

This issue has been moved from a ticket on Developer Community.

---

[severity:It’s more difficult to complete my work]
Microsoft Visual Studio Community 2022 (64-bit) - Current
Version 17.9.6
No formatting extensions installed.

When I type a closing brace } in a C# .razor file, the opening brace { is moved to a new line.
These are my options:
Text editor > Code Cleanup > Run Code Cleanup profile on save: ☐
Text editor > C# > General > Automatic brace completion: ☐
Text editor > C# > Code Style > Formatting > General > all ☐
Text editor > C# > Code Style > Formatting > New lines > New line options for braces: all ☐

Example before:

	private void OnPriceClick() {
		OrderBy(x => x.Price);
	}
  

Action: remove closing brace and add it back in the same spot.

Example after:

	private void OnPriceClick()
	{
		OrderBy(x => x.Price);
	}
  

Edit: I realised that the C# code is inside a .razor file and not a .cs file. This matters a lot as razor files have their own settings. Formatting works fine in .cs files.
I can mitigate the issue by disabling Text editor > Razor (ASP.NET Core) > Advanced > Format On Type
This reduces the severity.

---

Original Comments

Feedback Bot on 4/11/2024, 01:12 AM:

(private comment, text removed)

---

Original Solutions

(no solutions)

[Armageddon0]

I seem to be having a similar problem. First commented on issue dotnet/roslyn#75881, but was directed to file an issue with the Razor project as my issue seems to only be happening in .razor files. Searching through the issues already reported I found this one that seems very similar.

Here are my current Visual Studio formatting settings
Text Editor -> General

Text Editor -> Code Cleanup

Text Editor -> C# -> General

Text Editor -> C# -> Code Style -> Formatting

Text Editor -> C# -> Code Style -> Formatting -> New Lines

Text Editor -> Razor -> General

Text Editor -> Razor -> Advanced

Before updating to Visual Studio 17.12.0 everything appeared to be working as expected and my settings were being applied. Now however, it appears to be ignoring the new lines settings and thus when I run "Format Document" on a .razor file with Ctrl+K -> Ctrl+D it changes all braces to start on a new line.

Let me know if you need any further information.

[chenryIDSTC]

Same issue as @Armageddon0 here. On version 17.12.2.

[davidwengier]

This was fixed by dotnet/roslyn#76066. Apologies, I missed updating this issue.

[JarRami]

Still seeing the exact same behaviour as @Armageddon0 on version 17.12.4

[ryzngard]

The fix is shipped in current 17.13 previews and will be in 17.13 GA