ENR waku2 field always sets relay to true and others to false

[D4nte]

When trying different combination of the --relay, --store, --lightpush and --filter parameters with wakunode v0.9, it seems that the ENR URI displayed in the logs and returned in the info JSON RPC API always set the waku field to relay=true and the rest false.

There are extensive ENR testing in js-waku so I am starting to think the issue is on nwaku side.

See here the test cases against nwaku: https://github.com/status-im/js-waku/blob/11e6f91036563ca415bca8661a9da0a98bcabb8e/src/lib/enr/enr.node.spec.ts

Both Relay + Store and All test cases fail because the result is relay: true and the rest false.

nwaku_ENR_Interop_nwaku_All.log
nwaku_ENR_Interop_nwaku_Relay.log
nwaku_ENR_Interop_nwaku_Relay_+_Store.log

[D4nte]

Here are a couple of sample encoded by js-waku to help finding the issue:

all fields set to true:

enr:-IS4QJVLfEAZ8NJSrBZsG5Vj5N5O0Mv9X-8lA-txPAk7TqyyCK-s9UycO3Y5_J7QuQg6GshspV1HaFFQUGsIa1svUpECgmlkgnY0iXNlY3AyNTZrMaEDvI0lrq_uD81GkJDELPxfmX8X1WzqITL1tlmsYp6QHv6Fd2FrdTKIAQEBAQAAAAA

only relay set to true:

enr:-IS4QG4AsPPisSEDQC6kUQmxAu-KhlIHj-_GCKlEAotZQeN3AbwHC12_vCvL41cMeGNo1yhFwOxqe1CD0Pn_1iNEgfYCgmlkgnY0iXNlY3AyNTZrMaEDgB1FBFe2uFUPefSDFWkv15Eqmvjj5Vq7Zz66PncW9GiFd2FrdTKIAQAAAAAAAAA

only store set to true:

enr:-IS4QFzpeULt8QwnTvBZlJdFIhzaybADfj6VVNLcj143R7FhHAa_CZlZGwMintyyY7sESfnq_F5WlVRMdEboTCavkJsCgmlkgnY0iXNlY3AyNTZrMaECvybj-frAZ43FDjqh8yb-XMwfQsfH0PGnTSWO18aQ_liFd2FrdTKIAAEAAAAAAAA

[D4nte]

js-waku bug.

[kaiserd]

In the logs you showed, I can only find a DNS ENR, so I assume discv5 was not active.

The ENRs are

Relay + Store

enr:-KO4QMs915YD8gHiYnIB_b_wq5Me6LqTqd4upOm7yrPXbMIZZ_JMgfKBif6V5084LMkOO3oq2LCvPW6ykt3yiBxQa8EBgmlkgnY0gmlwhH8AAAGKbXVsdGlhZGRyc4wACgR_AAABBh9F3QOJc2VjcDI1NmsxoQO6A2BLBMCgMyigys5mBggiZtCGt-7h5mQuYAQ_DD0yiIN0Y3CCH0SFd2FrdTID

All

enr:-KO4QMs915YD8gHiYnIB_b_wq5Me6LqTqd4upOm7yrPXbMIZZ_JMgfKBif6V5084LMkOO3oq2LCvPW6ykt3yiBxQa8EBgmlkgnY0gmlwhH8AAAGKbXVsdGlhZGRyc4wACgR_AAABBh9F3QOJc2VjcDI1NmsxoQO6A2BLBMCgMyigys5mBggiZtCGt-7h5mQuYAQ_DD0yiIN0Y3CCH0SFd2FrdTID

Relay only

enr:-KO4QP18ugC5KQXW-ZFG5VRYXxs8VZD2Xg0nfAlpQAVXv5wOOi2hPxWOAt8NRsz2nFjxFWS7Yvvkfr5liw-c5Zokl6sBgmlkgnY0gmlwhH8AAAGKbXVsdGlhZGRyc4wACgR_AAABBh9C3QOJc2VjcDI1NmsxoQJmAiRqrmpocPCydF_0HP1QsFbJ0WgbwK217XnIh60V_4N0Y3CCH0GFd2FrdTIB

These all contain the respective flags.

What was the full cmd you ran?
In case you had --discv5-discovery active for some runs, consider there are two ENR versions: see #915.
(This should not cause the problem, just something to be aware of.)

[D4nte]

discv5 discovery was not active. Apologies for the waste of time, if it was a fundamental issue on js-waku side. Now fixed and merged.