Add natural=peninsula preset

[quincylvania]

OSM Tag(s)

natural=peninsula

How would you like this tag to see supported?

As a Preset

Label

Peninsula

Aliases

No response

Terms

No response

Link to OSM Wiki page

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:natural=peninsula

Status of the Tag

Approved

Usage of the tag

1600

Replaces other Tag?

No response

Regional Tag?

No response

Further Information

While there are relatively few uses, the tag is used for some large and important features (e.g. the Arabian Peninsula).

[matkoniecz]

Note the already controversial/problematic handling of bays and their name tagging - especially enormous ones.

[quincylvania]

@matkoniecz Are you saying we shouldn't add a preset for this? iD already has presets for bays, capes, islands… lots of similar large features.

[matkoniecz]

Are you saying we shouldn't add a preset for this?

Not entirely sure. If I would be then I would suggest either way.

Just mentioning that it is one of controversial tagging topics.

[tyrasd]

Thanks for pointing that out @matkoniecz .

similar large features

Another example for similarly large and fuzzy objects might be mountain ranges (e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/2698607), which iD still has no dedicated preset for.

shouldn't add a preset for this

iD should have presets also for this kind of objects. The main question would be whether we want to make it searchable or hidden. But whatever we decide, we should consistently use the same for all "similar" presets. IMHO, it's not a big concern that users of iD (& co) would use this preset to create "enormous" objects which might be considered problematic because of their size.

[1ec5]

If anyone manages to create one of the controversial monstrosities using iD, preset or no, they should win a prize.